How Do Children Feel About Open Adoption?

Research consistently shows that open adoption affects the child positively, with children in open adoption demonstrating better emotional adjustment, stronger identity formation, and higher self-esteem compared to those in closed adoptions. Understanding these benefits can help you feel confident that choosing open adoption creates the healthiest possible foundation for your child's emotional wellbeing and development.

We're here to help you understand how adopted children feel in open adoption relationships, what research tells us about their emotional development, and how ongoing connections with birth families contribute to healthier, happier children who thrive throughout their lives.

How Does Open Adoption Benefit the Child Emotionally?

How does open adoption affect the child emotionally? Research shows that children in open adoption experience significant emotional benefits that support their psychological development and overall wellbeing throughout their lives.

• Emotional Security and Trust: Children in open adoption develop stronger emotional security because they grow up with honesty and transparency about their story. Rather than wondering about their origins or feeling like part of their identity is hidden, they have access to information that helps them feel secure and whole.
• Reduced Anxiety and Wondering: How adopted children feel is significantly influenced by whether they have answers to their questions. Children in open adoption don't spend years wondering about their birth parents' wellbeing, appearance, or reasons for choosing adoption. This access to information reduces anxiety and helps them focus on their development rather than worrying about unknowns.
• Enhanced Self-Esteem: Research shows that children in open adoption have higher self-esteem because they understand that adoption came from love, not abandonment. They get to witness firsthand the caring relationship between their birth mother and adoptive parents, reinforcing that they are valued and loved by multiple people.
• Stronger Attachment with Adoptive Parents: Contrary to common fears, children in open adoption actually form stronger attachments with their adoptive parents. The transparency and honesty create deeper trust, and children don't have to choose between loyalties—they can love both their birth and adoptive families without conflict.
• Better Emotional Regulation: How does open adoption affect the child in terms of emotional regulation? Studies show that children with ongoing birth family contact demonstrate better emotional regulation skills because they have more complete understanding of their identity and story.
• Reduced Feelings of Rejection: Children in open adoption are less likely to interpret their adoption as rejection because they maintain relationships with their birth families. They understand that adoption was a loving choice made in their best interest, not a sign of being unwanted or unloved.

Will the Child Be Confused by Having Two Families?

One of the most common concerns birth mothers have is whether open adoption will confuse children, but research shows that it is not supported by evidence. With age-appropriate communication and guidance, children adapt beautifully to having extended loving relationships.

• How Children Understand Family Relationships: Children are naturally capable of understanding complex family relationships when they're explained honestly and age-appropriately. Just as children understand having grandparents, aunts, uncles, and step-families, they can understand having both birth and adoptive families who love them.
• Age-Appropriate Understanding: Young Children (Ages 2-6): Very young children simply accept their family structure as normal. They understand that their birth mother loved them so much she chose their adoptive parents to take care of them every day.
• School Age (Ages 7-12): Children this age can understand more complex explanations about why adoption happened and appreciate having ongoing relationships with birth families. They often feel proud of their unique family story.
• Teenagers (Ages 13-18): Adolescents typically appreciate having access to their birth families during this identity-formation period. Rather than causing confusion, ongoing relationships often provide valuable support during teenage years.

Clear Role Understanding: Children in open adoption learn early that they have:

• Adoptive Parents: The people who take care of them daily, make parenting decisions, and raise them
• Birth Family: The people who gave them life and chose their adoptive family because they loved them

This role clarity actually reduces confusion rather than creating it.

Benefits of Multiple Loving Relationships:

• Extended Support Network: Children benefit from having multiple adults who care about their wellbeing and success.
• Diverse Perspectives: Ongoing relationships provide children with different viewpoints, experiences, and support during various life stages.
• Identity Completeness: Rather than feeling confused, children feel more complete because they have access to all parts of their story and identity.

How Adoptive Parents Support Understanding: Good adoptive families help children understand their relationships by:

• Speaking positively about birth families
• Explaining adoption in age-appropriate ways
• Supporting ongoing contact and communication
• Answering questions honestly and openly

What Research Shows: Studies consistently demonstrate that confusion from open adoption is not a concern when families communicate openly and honestly. Children in open adoption show:

• Better understanding of their adoption story
• More positive feelings about being adopted
• Stronger sense of identity and belonging
• Less confusion about family relationships than children in closed adoptions

What Do Adoptees Say About Growing Up in Open Adoption?

Adult adoptees who grew up in open adoption provide valuable insights into how adopted children feel about their experiences and the long-term benefits of maintaining birth family relationships.

Common Themes from Adoptee Experiences:

• Gratitude for Honesty: Adult adoptees consistently express gratitude for growing up with honesty and transparency about their adoption story.
• Appreciation for Birth Mother's Choice: Most adoptees from open adoption express deep appreciation for their birth mother's decision and understand the love behind the choice.
• Strong Identity Formation: Adult adoptees report feeling more secure in their identity because they had access to information about their origins and background.
• Positive Family Relationships: Most maintain positive relationships with both birth and adoptive families into adulthood.
• Reduced Adoption Issues: Adult adoptees from open adoption report fewer of the identity struggles, abandonment feelings, and adoption-related issues that commonly affect those from closed adoptions.

What Adoptees Want Birth Mothers to Know:

• Your Love is Evident: Adult adoptees understand that open adoption demonstrates love, not abandonment.
• Ongoing Relationships Matter: Most value their ongoing relationships with birth families and credit these connections with their emotional wellbeing.
• You Made the Right Choice: Adult adoptees consistently affirm that their birth mothers made loving, selfless decisions that created positive outcomes.
• Pride in Their Story: Most adult adoptees from open adoption feel proud of their unique family story and the love that created it.

Does Open Adoption Help the Child Understand Their Story?

Yes, open adoption provides children with comprehensive understanding of their story, which is crucial for healthy identity development and emotional wellbeing.

The importance of understanding their story:

• Identity Formation: Children need to understand their complete story to develop healthy identity and sense of self. Open adoption provides access to the full narrative rather than leaving gaps or mysteries.
• Medical History Access: Ongoing relationships ensure children have access to updated medical information throughout their lives, which is crucial for healthcare decisions.
• Cultural and Family Heritage: Open adoption allows children to understand and appreciate their cultural background, family traditions, and heritage in ways that closed adoption cannot provide.
• Birth Family Characteristics: Children get to understand where they inherited certain traits, talents, interests, and characteristics, which helps them feel more complete and self-aware.

How open adoption facilitates understanding:

• Direct Communication: Children can ask questions directly to their birth families and receive honest, age-appropriate answers about their adoption story.
• Ongoing Updates: Rather than having static information from birth, children receive updated information about birth family developments, which keeps their story current and relevant.
• Visual Connection: Through photos, videos, and visits, children can see resemblances and connections that help them understand their place in their biological family tree.
• Relationship Context: Ongoing relationships help children understand the emotional context of their adoption and the love that motivated the decision.

Age-Appropriate Story Development:

• Early Childhood: Young children learn simple, positive explanations about being chosen and loved by both families.
• School Age: Children can understand more complex aspects of their story and begin appreciating the sacrifice and love involved in their adoption.
• Adolescence: Teenagers can process the full complexity of their story and often develop deep appreciation for their birth mother's decision during this identity-formation period.
• Adulthood: Adult adoptees from open adoption have complete understanding of their story and can make informed decisions about ongoing relationships.

Benefits of Story Completeness:

• Reduced Fantasy and Worry: Children don't create unrealistic fantasies about their birth families or worry about their wellbeing when they have ongoing contact.
• Better Self-Understanding: Access to complete story information helps children understand themselves more fully and develop stronger self-awareness.
• Emotional Processing: Children can process their adoption story with support from both birth and adoptive families rather than struggling with questions alone.
• Pride in Origin: Rather than feeling shame or confusion about their origins, children develop pride in their unique story and the love that created it.

Is Open Adoption Always the Best Choice for the Child?

While research consistently shows positive outcomes for children in open adoption, it's important to acknowledge that it depends on the quality of relationships and the commitment of all parties involved.

When Open Adoption Benefits Children Most:

• Healthy Relationships: Open adoption provides the greatest benefits when birth mothers, children, and adoptive families maintain healthy, respectful relationships with appropriate boundaries.
• Committed Families: Children benefit most when adoptive families are genuinely committed to open adoption and view birth family relationships as valuable rather than burdensome.
• Professional Support: Open adoption works best when families have access to professional support for relationship maintenance and communication challenges.
• Appropriate Boundaries: Children thrive when open adoption relationships have clear, healthy boundaries that respect everyone's roles and needs.

Factors That Influence Success:

• Communication Quality: The benefits of open adoption are maximized when families communicate respectfully and honestly while maintaining appropriate boundaries.
• Stability and Consistency: Children benefit most from consistent, stable contact rather than sporadic or unpredictable communication.
• Child-Centered Approach: Open adoption works best when all parties prioritize the child's wellbeing and emotional needs above their own preferences.
• Flexibility Over Time: Successful open adoption relationships can adapt and evolve as children grow and their needs change.

Individual Considerations:

• Birth Mother Readiness: Open adoption works best when birth mothers feel emotionally ready for ongoing relationships and have realistic expectations.
• Adoptive Family Commitment: Children benefit most when adoptive families genuinely embrace open adoption rather than reluctantly agreeing to contact.
• Child's Temperament: While most children benefit from open adoption, individual personality traits and needs may influence how much contact feels comfortable.
• Family Dynamics: The quality of relationships between all parties significantly influences the effects.

Alternative Approaches:

• Semi-Open Adoption: Some children benefit from semi-open arrangements where information is shared through agencies rather than direct contact.
• Flexible Openness: Some families benefit from starting with limited contact and gradually increasing openness as relationships develop.
• Minimal Contact: Occasionally, minimal contact with periodic updates works better for certain family situations.

How an Adoption Agency Can Support the Child's Wellbeing

Quality adoption agencies play a crucial role in ensuring that open adoption affects the child positively by providing ongoing support, relationship facilitation, and child-centered services throughout the adoption journey.

Pre-Placement Child-Centered Services:

• Family Matching: Agencies help ensure that children are placed with families who are genuinely committed to open adoption and understand its benefits for child development.
• Relationship Planning: Professional agencies help birth mothers and adoptive families develop child-centered communication plans that prioritize the child's emotional wellbeing.
• Education and Preparation: Agencies provide education to all parties about how adopted children feel in open adoption and how to support healthy development.
• Expectation Setting: Professional services help ensure that all parties have realistic expectations about open adoption relationships and their impact on children.

Post-Placement Child Support:

• Ongoing Relationship Facilitation: Agencies continue supporting open adoption relationships to ensure they remain healthy and beneficial for children as they grow and develop.
• Communication Mediation: When communication challenges arise, agencies provide professional mediation to help maintain child-centered focus and resolve conflicts.
• Developmental Guidance: As children grow, agencies provide guidance about age-appropriate communication and involvement levels.
• Crisis Intervention: If relationship problems develop, agencies provide intervention services to protect children's emotional wellbeing.

Why Agency Support Matters for Children:

• Professional Expertise: Agencies have specialized knowledge about how adopted children feel and develop in open adoption relationships.
• Neutral Mediation: Professional agencies provide neutral support that prioritizes children's needs above adult preferences or conflicts.
• Long-term Perspective: Agencies understand child development and can help ensure that open adoption relationships continue supporting children throughout their growth.
• Crisis Prevention: Professional support helps prevent relationship problems that could negatively impact children's emotional wellbeing.

Learn About Our Child-Centered Support Services

Learning about how open adoption affects a child reveals overwhelmingly positive outcomes for children who grow up with ongoing birth family relationships. Research consistently shows that children in open adoption demonstrate better emotional adjustment, stronger identity formation, higher self-esteem, and greater life satisfaction compared to those in closed adoptions.

How adopted children feel about their experience is significantly more positive when they have access to their complete story, ongoing relationships with birth families, and honest communication about their adoption. Rather than causing confusion, open adoption helps children understand their unique family structure and feel proud of the love that created their story.

Adult adoptees from open adoption consistently express gratitude for growing up with transparency and ongoing relationships. They understand that adoption came from love, not abandonment, and credit their ongoing birth family connections with their emotional wellbeing and strong identity formation.

While are open adoptions better for the child in most cases, success depends on having committed families, healthy relationships, and professional support. Quality adoption agencies play a crucial role in ensuring that open adoption relationships remain child-centered and beneficial throughout the child's development.

Disclaimer
Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.